Nivedita Mishra is a writer from Hindustan Times. She wrote her feedback on Puli's teaser and then again on the trailer released few days ago. We don't have anything personal against the writer but we thought to write our reply to what she has written. The post will be a part from the article and our reply to that particular part.
First thing the writer knows the word fantasy but looks like she is mixing between fantasy and historical. That is the First Mistake. Fantasy is completely different than historical. Definition of fantasy is imagination especially when extravagant and unrestrained.
And how does Fantasy genre in films  defined? it is something that contains rudiments that are not realistic, such as magical powers, talking animals, etc. Fantasy is often characterized by a departure from the accepted rules by which individuals perceive the world around them; it represents that which is impossible (unexplained) and outside the parameters of our known, reality. Make-believe is what this genre is all about. A fantasy has no language, land or look.

Second Mistake: The writer maybe have not watched enough movies. Nivedita ji haven't you seen Hollywood produced films like Aladdin or Sinbad? These and many other films were loved by audience and critics & we have not seen Hollywood critics say that Sinbad was not white or blue eyed! they did not say that western people should not wear these clothes! Why? because their critics know the meaning of the word fantasy and you don't. See the below picture. This is Sinbad! White with blue eyes!
Why go to Hollywood. Have you seen Bollywood films? Haven't you seen films like Alibaba Aur 40 Chor? Ajooba or even Dharmendra's Superman? Do you think Indians should not make movies that has a bit of Persian/Arab culture or Western look? A fantasy film has no land, no language. A fantasy film can happen anywhere. Puli is no different here. 

Third Mistake: Writer has assumed that Puli is taking place in India! This is not true, Puli is not taking place in India simply because it is a fantasy film. Just because the film is made in India does not necessarily mean it takes place there. Names, places and everything about the movie is completely fictional. That is what a fantasy is about.
Fourth Mistake: The writer keeps repeating herself again and again. Her problem is that the look of the film is western and the film is an Indian one! Did you see films like Vikram Bhatt's 1920? Did India look like that or Indian wear like that in the 1920s? Did you watch Sanjay Leela Bhansali's Guzaarish? Where was the setting of the film? Do Indians wear like that? bearing in mind that both these films were not even fantasies! One was a horror film and the other was more a romantic drama. 
Fifth Mistake: Why does Puli have to be Baahubali? These are two different films with two different genres! How can you compare the two? Other than both being made with high budget and with lots of CGI use there is no other similarity! Actually we are glad that Puli is so different. Kudos to the makers for making it very different. The writer wants every movie to look the same to her own taste, That is not going to happen.
For all the above the writer gets a thumb down from us and Hindustan Times also gets another thumb down for posting this article not once but twice.

Our advise to the respected writer Nivedita Mishra is to grab a dictionary and learn the correct meaning of the word Fantasy!


To read the original article by the writer click HERE
 


Comments

kv
24/08/2015 5:16am

This is great reply
Well written

Reply
Sudesh
24/08/2015 11:08pm

Well replied. These are the same critics who complain that novelty doesn't exist. When someone tries to do something different then they complain again comparing.

Reply
Diya
25/08/2015 4:46am

Well said..good reply for all those who compare movies and kill it even before release..

Reply
31/08/2015 9:50am

Your replies to the writer Nivedita is good and it is the best way to speak in favor of what you did and what is the actual meaning of the film. There are so many fans of Sridevi and they follow her.

Reply
28/09/2015 1:09am

Very good blog for all readers.

Reply

Nice article for everybody.

Reply
29/09/2015 10:25am

Thanks for sharing this post. Good one! Please check this website to know everything about this special area of Western Uttar Pradesh, India
http://apnabaraut.in/

Reply

No Escape is a movie must be watched by people who love to travel and explore the world. Although the movie is not produced in a single country rather it presents the scenes very attractive of many different countries. And watching such movie could be very useful for the tourists.

Reply
09/03/2016 12:04pm

Shri Devi is one of best and well known actoress in the Bollywood. He is also very beautiful.

Reply
13/03/2016 10:59am

From all of the famous and talented actresses the Sridevi is one which won the heart of people. They do their work in an efficient manner that attracts the viewers towards them.

Reply
26/03/2016 3:38am

I located a desirable understanding on your blog site. I also advise this blog with my friends

Reply
01/05/2016 9:35pm

The idea continues to be appreciably viewed as by simply first prefer to research as well as internet websites that is certainly valuable to every person to master relating to imagination such a because Most of us might easily review to generate a web web page.

Reply
29/07/2016 3:06am

Easily, the article is actually the best topic on this registry related issue. I fit in with your conclusions and will eagerly look forward to your next updates. Just saying thanks will not just be sufficient, for the fantasti c lucidity in your writing. I will instantly grab your rss feed to stay informed of any updates.

Reply
01/08/2016 2:46am

his is my first time i visit here. I found so many entertaining stuff in your blog, especially its discussion. From the tons of comments on your articles, I guess I am not the only one having all the leisure here! Keep up the excellent work.

Reply
14/08/2016 4:18pm

I thumb down was shown in Indian times for the new movie of Shri Devi. According to them, she did not perform well but in my opinion she is best and evergreen actress of Bollywood. I love her way of acting.

Reply
17/09/2016 10:24pm

If you're a writer, or you want to be a writer, then you need write more and earn more. Now that might be easy to say but maybe not as easy to do if you don't know how.

Reply
25/10/2016 3:43am

Its like you learn my mind! You seem to know a lot about this, such as you wrote the eBook in it or something. I think that you simply can do with some p.c. to drive the message house a little bit, but instead of that, that is great blog. A great read. I'll certainly be back.

Reply

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply